Inquiry Post #4: Advancing Equity through Technology

Understanding the Digital Divide 

    The term digital divide has changed since its formation in the mid 1990's. 30 years ago, it was "the uneven distribution of information and communication technologies (ICT) in society" (Britannica, 2024). This divide can be between industrialized and developing countries (global divide), socioeconomic groups (social divide) or based on usage for political engagement (political divide). It is believed to reinforce the social inequalities and correlates to a persistent information and knowledge gap between those with access (sometimes called the 'haves') and those without ('have- nots').

    The divide can occur at two levels. A first- level divide is defined as differences in access to computer and the Internet. This can be seen in the global or social divide. Second- level divides look at differences in computer and internet usage, as such in a political divide.

    A US study done by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration in 1995 found that those in more rural, less affluent areas, those that had less education, older generations and migrant/ ethnic minorities were among those with the least access and usage because it was difficult to run cables that far and it was expensive (NTIA, 1995). There was also initially a gender gap, with men having easier access than women. Not only was there less access but that was often combined with a lack of navigational skills; they didn't know how to use the technology to do research or learn and mainly used it for entertainment.

    Jaeger et al. (2012) found that the recent digital divide looks more specifically at usage and participation rather than access because technology has changed so much (4). Internet access has increased generally, especially with the inclusion of smartphones that have given a lot more personal access, but it also became less expensive. They also found that libraries are the most heavily relied on public institution to overcome the divide yet they are often excluded from funding and the decision- making process for policy creation (22).

Canadian Library Systems

    For Canada, the library system was really impacted by the Covid- 19 pandemic and lockdowns/ closures. Intahchomphoo and Vellino found that this was librarians' most difficult time period because they had to go directly from physical resources and in- person service to digital/ online with no down time (42). This impacted patrons in many ways that I hadn't considered before. Services like using printers to print applications or forms, using computers for job searches and bus schedules, were reduced entirely, leaving many with disabilities with an increase in barriers to not just technology access but often to general life as well. Ways that libraries modified and adapted services included extending wi-fi to parking lots and removing a password requirement, online printing orders with curbside pick- up, and lending out laptops or tablets to community partners like food banks and housing facilities so those with physical disabilities could still get access (43). Intahchomphoo and Vellino surveyed patrons from across Canada to get their recommendations for addressing the digital divide. Suggestions all surrounded money and funding; they said libraries should be a part of the funding process at all levels of government and get increases to funding specifically for technology development, increases in internet speed and quality and more funding for on- to- one programming for digital literacy skills.

Library Initiatives

    Locally, my library network (Thompson- Nicola Regional Libraries) has made changes to their policies, because of the pandemic but also (perhaps incidentally, perhaps intentionally) to provide better/ more access to a wider patron audience. These changes include cancelling late/ overdue fees, increasing technology skill classes and services specifically targetting elderly folks and newcomers to Canada/ Kamloops, and creating resources in more languages to address the increasingly diverse population. It is also heartening to see a page dedicated to resources about the local Indigenous language, Secwepemctsin.

Works Cited

Intahchomphoo, C., & Vellino, A. (2024). Canadian Public Library Pandemic Response: Bridging the Digital Divide and Preparing for Future Pandemics. The Canadian Journal of Information and Library Science, 47(1), 37-51.

Jaeger, P. T., Bertot, J. C., Thompson, K. M., Katz, S. M., & DeCoster, E. J. (2012). The intersection of public policy and public access: Digital divides, digital literacy, digital inclusion, and public libraries. Public library quarterly, 31(1), 1-20.

US Department of Commerce. (1995). “Falling Through the Net: A Survey of the ‘Have Nots’ in Rural and Urban America”. National Telecommunications and Information Administration. 

Schweitzer, Eva Johanna.  “Digital Divide: Bridging the Gap in Society”. Britannica. Oct. 3, 2024.

Comments

  1. I appreciate how you have detailed the adaptations libraries made as a result of the pandemic. The quote, “libraries are the most heavily relied on public institution to overcome the divide yet they are often excluded from funding and the decision-making process for policy creation,” effectively highlights the critical role libraries play and the challenges they face. I feel that this is true for SLLCs as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for sharing, Katy. This is a helpful post with well researched information. I did not know there was this second level divide, in what seems to be related to political divides. It is also interesting to see how research is continuing to find well researched evidence about how the pandemic affected libraries. I was not yet in the teaching world during the pandemic, and seeing this research is not surprising, but I am curious if libraries have 'bounced back' since the pandemic.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for sharing! I didn't realize the extend that libraries changed their services to support people during the pandemic. I wonder if these services will continue with the regular in person services as they could continue supporting people who might like the option to continue to use the services at home.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment